Last night, I was watching some great women’s gymnastics when something happened that really kind of bothered me. I am all about sportsmanship and fairness when it comes to this thing, because it really is the only thing that the world can come together on and participate in and not fight over (and if they do, they usually just get pissy, and that’s about it). Well, the girls were doing the uneven bars, and the two top girls, one from China, and one from the USA, both had the same start difficulty value, AND they both scored exactly the same on their routines. Well, one would think that since they were both the top scorers, then they would both share a gold medal. However, that is not what happened. They pulled some bullshit “tie breaking” procedural crap, and gave the gold to the Chinese girl, and the American girl got the silver; even though they both scored the same! It was bullshit. I felt bad for the American girl, because she clearly deserved the gold as well. It was just fucked up, really, because of all the “rules” they have in place to make it “fair”, and all it does is make it fair for one, but completely UNFAIR for the other. I just felt like it puts a damper on the spirit of the games when it isn’t based on your performance, or your ability, and instead comes down to algorithms and shit like that. I just don’t see how you can score the same, and one of you is still made to be second. Oh well.
seen recently
-
2010-03-01 03:04
Funniest movie of 2009; still funny in 2010! Watching this movie is such a great time!
0.3 -
2010-02-28 17:47
Oh wow, what a mess. This was a big budget movie that should have been a straight to DVD, or a second rate cable movie. Seriously, who thought this was good? Also, I know a lot of people are all, "Megan Fox is sooooo gorgeous", but this movie just made her look average. Ouch.
0.3 -
2010-02-28 17:45
Wow, this was bad. I seriously said to myself 3 or 4 times that I should just turn it off, but something kept me from doing it. After seeing the whole film, I really dislike that something.
0.3 -
2010-02-28 17:41
If I could describe this movie with one word, it would be intense. A gripping look at a soldier that is in it for the adrenaline, this movie is raw, gritty, and feels very real. I see Oscars coming to this film next month.
0.3 -
2010-02-17 16:57
Enjoyable from beginning to end. I love this movie; it is funny, action packed, and down right fun.
0.3
The American girl was ten times prettier.
She was probably 10 times older too.
Seriously though… you’re right, she should have the gold as well. But I think if this had happened in the US of A it might have gone the opposite direction. I wonder how many times that’s happened in Olympic history… hmm…
They should have just let it be a tie. Then everyone could have had a gold. I wonder what criteria they used for the tie breaker?
Bull.Shit.
Yeah.. at first, I thought “well surely they can explain what happened and it will all make sense.” but no. They explained it… but it didn’t make sense.
” The A jury (two judges) calculates the score for difficulty and technical content. Both were given 7.7 start values.
The B jury (six judges) decided the execution score by deducting from the old standard of a perfect 10.
The highest and lowest marks are eliminated, and the score is the average of the four remaining judges. This is then added to the start value. Both gymnasts earned an identical 16.725.
Then the first tie breaker rule was implemented, where an average of the four counting B jury deductions are taken into account for each gymnast. They were still tied.
Then the highest deduction of the four was discarded, and the remaining three were again averaged. This is where He finally sneaked ahead as her average deduction was 0.933 compared with Liukin’s 0.966. Understand? Neither did a lot of people.”
The important part is the last part… where they threw out the highest deduction. Uh.. Why? So what you’re saying is that the worst fuckup in the routine was done by the one who ended up winning the gold medal? O_o
I’m offended by your lack of respect for algorithms.
mingaling… LOL not all algorithms, just the one they used. LOL
Yes I was glued to the set the past couple of weeks. I have been killing myself to stay up some nights just to see the girls compete. I must say that I am a little jaded at the fact that there is so much controversy around the ages of these chinese athletes. I read tonight where they have found more evidence that He is not the “legal” age to compete. Is that America being a sore loser? I don’t know. But I will say this, the rules are set to make every thing fair…. But when you have a government that has the power and the ability to tell you when you were born it makes you wonder. In the end, I hope that the truth prevails and everyone is treated accordingly. I must say that Nastia handled the situation like a very mature competitor and I am still in awe of her composure, YOU GO GIRL!