imitation, the sincerest form of flattery?

I was reading one of my many music blogs this afternoon, when I happened upon the following music clip (via discopop directory):


After listening for about 20 seconds, I had this sneaking suspicion that I had heard this song before… Hmmm, where have I heard that same drumming, same guitar riff, and same distortion effect? That’s right… Muse’s Knights of Cydonia:

Well, I guess if you are going to copy a song, at least copy an amazing one, right? What I don’t get, is that I have never seen the amazing allure that the Arctic Monkeys have to them, and this just makes me question it even more… And I am not really familiar with the Rascals as of this writing. Oh well, perhaps they meant it as an homage to Muse, who are in their own right, a truly amazing band. I just wonder why they had to make it so damn similar, you know? The similarity was instantly recognizable to me, and I am sure that I am not alone in that sentiment.

What are your thoughts? What do you think when you hear an amazing song rehashed by a group that may be more commercially popular, but not necessarily any “better”, as far as you concerned? How does it make you feel when said “copied” group is a group that you really enjoy, but the other isn’t, and you know that they will have more success with their clone?

2 Responses to “imitation, the sincerest form of flattery?”


  1. Gravatar Icon 1 docjohnboy Mar 27th, 2008 at 8:06 pm

    Well I’ll say this. The Muse video is much better. A fucking unicorn in the desert. Brilliant.

  2. Gravatar Icon 2 Doug Mar 27th, 2008 at 9:55 pm

    For a while I hated them taking samples of 80’s new wave songs and putting them into hip hop songs. But then I figure I love me some good remakes of old songs turned into dance numbers (do we remember Kylie’s the Locomotion?) so who am I to talk.

    Not sure about those Monkeys, either. I wonder if they paid for the rights to the riffs?

Leave a Reply




    categoricalness

    achivalness